In concert with National Family Caregivers Month, Dr. Brandon G. Wilson shared his thoughts on rural caregiving – and the crisis behind it – in a new whitepaper. We have taken some sections for a shortened piece here, but encourage readers to check out the full document.

In communities across America, the largest health workforce is not employed by a hospital, clinic, or health system. It receives no formal training, appears in no workforce projections, and is rarely included in policy discussions about healthcare staffing shortages. Yet it provides billions of hours of care each year and serves as the backbone of long-term services and supports. These workers are family caregivers. 

America now has approximately 63 million family caregivers, representing nearly one in four adults and a dramatic increase over the past decade. More than 40 percent provide what researchers describe as “high-intensity care.” Roughly 70 percent help monitor health conditions and coordinate care. Yet only a small share report receiving formal training.  

I was one of them. 

However, for years I did not think of myself as a caregiver. I thought I was helping my mom. The irony is that, even working in health policy and health system transformation for decades, I did not recognize what I was doing had a name. Like millions of family members across the country, I did all the things needed to manage my mother’s care – juggling appointments and medication, talking with doctors, navigating a maze of Medicare and Medicaid rules, and more. Doing my best to make sure nothing slipped through the cracks. 

At the time, I would not have described this as care coordination or care management. Looking back, that is exactly what it was. What strikes me today is not how unusual that experience was. It is how common it is. 

Every November, we celebrate and uplift the labor provided by family caregivers who are performing many of the same functions that accountable care organizations and a host of other innovative population health and payment models were designed to improve. Yet while physicians, hospitals, health systems, and accountable care organizations are rewarded financially for generating better outcomes and lower costs, caregivers who make those outcomes possible receive supportive message but remain largely invisible within our financing systems. When looking at what caregivers are sacrificing financially elsewhere in their lives to keep the healthcare systems afloat, that omission is becoming increasingly harder to justify. 

The Hidden Subsidy Holding Healthcare Together 

National caregiving research consistently finds that family caregivers pay a significant financial price for the care they provide. Many reduce their work hours. Others leave the workforce entirely. Many lose wages, retirement contributions, opportunities for promotion, and years of future earnings. Some take on debt. Others struggle to afford basic household expenses while simultaneously helping a loved one navigate illness, disability, or aging. 

The financial consequences do not end when caregiving responsibilities end. Reduced lifetime earnings, retirement savings, and Social Security credits can follow caregivers for decades. Viewed individually, these losses may appear to be personal sacrifices. Viewed collectively, they are a transfer of cost. While family caregivers help Medicare beneficiaries remain stable, support Medicaid recipients in the community, prevent avoidable hospitalizations, and sustain rural health systems amid workforce shortages, they are financing part of the healthcare system with their own time, income, retirement security, and future economic opportunity. 

That reality forces an uncomfortable question – if family caregivers are generating value for healthcare organizations, health plans, accountable care entities, Medicare and Medicaid, why are they also the ones bearing so much of the financial risk? In most sectors of the economy, people who help create value share in at least some portion of the returns. In caregiving, the opposite often occurs. The system captures the value. Caregivers absorb the cost.  

That is why caregiving should not be viewed as a family issue or even a support-services issue. It is simultaneously a workforce, retirement security, rural health and health-financing issue. Because one of the largest subsidies in American healthcare does not come from a government program, a grant, or a payment model. It comes from millions of family caregivers whose labor remains largely unpaid, uncounted and economically invisible. 

The Federal Government Can – And Should – Pay Family Caregivers  

Family caregiving has long been framed as an act of love and an expression of cultural values. It is both. But it is also labor, on which health systems, Medicare, Medicaid and accountable care organizations increasingly depend. Earlier generations of caregiver policy emphasized awareness and support. The next must address integration, sustainability and shared value.   

The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI) should test that proposition. A demonstration model could require participating healthcare organizations to identify family caregivers, assess their needs, include them in care planning, provide training and respite supports, and share a portion of savings when caregivers help improve outcomes and avert unnecessary utilization. The goal would not be to place a price on familial love or turn every family member into a paid healthcare worker. It would be to test whether recognizing and sustaining caregivers as part of the care team improves outcomes for patients, reduces avoidable costs, and strengthens the workforce on which accountable care already depends. 

A system that depends on caregivers while failing to sustain them is not solving its workforce challenge. It is transferring that challenge to families. If we want a healthcare system that rewards those who improve outcomes, strengthen care coordination, and reduce unnecessary costs, then caregivers can no longer remain invisible to the models intended to create that value. This November, we need to recognize the family caregivers in this country for their values and their value.